When you walk into a jewellery store, everything sparkles. But behind all that shine—what really matters? Whether you're investing in a custom engagement ring, a once-in-a-lifetime anniversary gift, or just want to treat yourself, recognizing quality craftsmanship is key.
At Mark Katzeff, every piece is made with intention, skill, and decades of goldsmithing expertise. But how can you tell what makes a piece worth your time and money? Let’s break it down.
Key Takeaways
-
Quality craftsmanship in jewelry goes beyond appearance—it’s about construction, materials, and detail.
-
A good jewellery store is transparent, knowledgeable, and offers custom work backed by in-house expertise.
-
Edmonton locals can benefit from working with an established artisan like Mark Katzeff for long-term value and personalization.
-
Knowing the signs of poor workmanship helps you avoid overpriced or mass-produced pieces.
-
Ask the right questions and know what to look for when visiting a local jewellery store.
What Is "Craftsmanship" in Jewelry, Really?
Craftsmanship is the invisible signature of the maker. It’s how cleanly a diamond is set, how smooth the metal feels, and how symmetrical the design is when you look closely. You might not always notice quality right away—but you’ll definitely feel the difference in how a piece wears and lasts.
Handmade vs Mass-Produced
Mass-produced jewelry often relies on machines and shortcuts to churn out high volume at the lowest cost. While it may look nice under display lighting, these pieces often lack refinement and durability.
Handmade jewelry, like what we create at Mark Katzeff, tells a different story. Each design is intentional. Every stone is hand-set. You’re not just buying a ring—you’re investing in the legacy of skilled craftsmanship.
Signs of Quality Craftsmanship
1. Smooth Finish with No Sharp Edges
Run your fingers along the edge of a ring or pendant. Is it comfortable to wear? Well-made pieces are smoothed and polished carefully—especially at contact points.
2. Secure, Even Stone Settings
Loose stones are a major red flag. Settings should be tight and symmetrical. Prongs should not snag on clothing, and bezels should lie flush with the gem.
3. Balanced Proportions
Whether it’s a ring, necklace, or bracelet, everything should look and feel balanced. Poorly made jewelry often has awkward spacing or uneven weights.
4. Durable Materials
Look for solid gold, platinum, or sterling silver (not plated!). Ask about gemstone hardness and resistance to wear. At Mark Katzeff, we help clients select metals and stones that align with both their lifestyle and their style.
5. Hallmarks and Maker’s Mark
Jewelry should have a stamp that indicates metal quality (e.g., 18K, 925). Many master goldsmiths, like Mark Katzeff, also include a personal maker’s mark as a sign of authenticity.
Questions to Ask Your Jeweller
When shopping for fine jewelry, asking the right questions can help you separate true artisans from fast fashion retailers.
“Is this piece handmade or cast?”
Handmade pieces tend to have more character and better finishing. Cast items are more uniform—but often lack the fine attention to detail.
“Who made this piece?”
A store that designs and fabricates in-house (like Mark Katzeff) will proudly share the story and people behind their work.
“Can you walk me through the materials?”
Transparency is everything. A reputable jeweller will explain the origin, grade, and durability of the metal and gemstones used.
“Can this piece be resized or repaired?”
Craftsmanship also means long-term usability. We design jewelry that can evolve with your life, from resizing to restyling.
Why Local Expertise Matters
Edmonton Is Full of Chain Stores—But Local Matters More
While chain jewelry stores might offer convenience or discounts, they often lack the personal touch, transparency, and technical skill that a local expert provides.
At Mark Katzeff, you're not just choosing a piece of jewelry—you’re choosing over 40 years of expertise, local reputation, and hands-on design.
You Get to Be Part of the Process
From sketches to stone selection, you’re included every step of the way. This means fewer surprises—and a much more meaningful final piece.
Real Relationships
Having a local goldsmith in your corner means you can come back any time for cleaning, resizing, upgrades, or future designs.
Watch Out for Red Flags
Here are some warning signs that a jewellery store may not value true craftsmanship:
-
Vague answers when you ask about materials or origins
-
Lack of proper certifications or metal stamps
-
Overuse of the word "custom" without showing actual custom processes
-
Pushy sales tactics focused only on price
If a piece seems too cheap to be true—it probably is. And even if it’s expensive, price doesn’t always mean quality. That’s why it pays to know what to look for.
What Makes Mark Katzeff the Gold Standard?
-
In-House Design & Fabrication: Nothing is outsourced. Every piece is crafted right here in Edmonton.
-
One-on-One Consultations: We take time to understand your vision, budget, and style.
-
Custom Restoration Services: We breathe new life into heirlooms or redesign inherited pieces into something fresh.
-
Certified Stones & Materials: Ethically sourced. Expertly selected.
-
Generational Craftsmanship: With decades of experience, Mark brings both skill and passion to each piece.
Final Thoughts
Spotting craftsmanship isn’t about being a jewelry expert—it’s about knowing what to value, asking the right questions, and trusting someone who’s earned it.
Whether you're marking a milestone or simply want to invest in something beautiful and lasting, don’t settle for mass-produced. Choose craftsmanship. Choose personal service. Choose Mark Katzeff.
Ready to See the Difference?
Visit our Edmonton studio to explore the difference true craftsmanship makes. Whether you're designing from scratch or upgrading something special, we're here to help.
Book a free consultation with Mark Katzeff today and start your journey toward a piece that’s made to last a lifetime.